This is one minister of a small church sharing with others in a simliar boat some of the stuff I've done on the basis that you'll have some I can pinch another time.  Puzzle pages seem to go down well in our church magazine, and most months I make up a word search (bad move - people might be tempted do it during the sermon!).  Here are this year's Christmas offerings, if they're any use.  NB if you spot errors feel free to fix them, I'm not offering any answers and the first one I got online from here (they have lots of quizzes with answers available free to use).

Have fun!